Your Local Indianapolis Diamond Buyer

We value more than just diamonds.


We ask you to please comply with the following guidelines while in our office during this time.


Only ONE client at a time


A face mask is required


Bring minimal items to your appt.


Practice safe social distancing


If you are feeling ill AT ALL, please contact us to reschedule your appointment.

The Indy Diamond Buyer Process

We believe that wisdom and reliability go hand in hand. When you put your trust in our diamond buying process, you can rest easy knowing our experts have over 60 years of accumulated experience in the diamond buying business in Indianapolis. We follow strict safety precautions to ensure that you have the freedom to sell us your diamond in a secure and private location. You can relax knowing that we are with you every step of the way.


Any documents that you can provide from a gemological lab or even a receipt from the original purchase will allow us to provide a more accurate estimate. If you don’t have any documentation, we are still able to continue with our process. We buy certified and non-certified diamonds.


Contact us to make an appointment for your diamond evaluation. Our priority is your safety and privacy. Unlike other Indianapolis diamond buyers, you will have the opportunity to sell your diamond in a respected and protected manner. You will enjoy our confidentiality and personal attention.


We pride ourselves on complete transparency in our process. Our goal is to help you understand every aspect of the different elements involved in evaluating your diamond. You deserve to know exactly how much your diamond is truly worth, as well as the current market trends.


Our years of experience and our promise to uphold fair and honest business practices, allow us to offer you the best price for your diamond. Our expert gemologist will complete your diamond evaluation and provide you with the highest offer, based on current market trends.


The best part of the entire process is that you are able to leave the same day with cash in hand. Not only that, the market is always changing and you can rely on us to always stay on top of these constant adjustments. We guarantee that you will receive first-rate treatment as well as the highest prices.


At the end of the process, you will receive a detailed receipt of your transaction.

Meet With Our Experts

Set up a meeting with our highly skilled gemologist with the luxury of a safe and exclusive setting.

About Indy Diamond Buyer


Where you choose to sell your diamonds in Indianapolis is important. We believe you deserve a buyer with integrity, experience and the ability to provide a safe setting for a diamond evaluation. We have a combined 60+ years of experience and our commitment to transparency means you are guaranteed an honest and accurate evaluation. Our knowledge of the market allows us to provide you with the best offers and cash in hand the same day.

We buy natural diamonds directly from the public.

Come to us if you want to sell large diamonds of 3.0 carats and even 4.0 carats and up. Bring us your diamond engagement ring or your diamonds from Forever Mark, Hearts on Fire, Tiffany & Co., or Cartier. You can sell us your loose diamonds too.

Our team is uniquely qualified to offer you notably higher prices than you would receive at a jewelry store, consignment shop or auction. You will also benefit from our confidentiality and security. We know that selling your diamonds can be an emotional process. So, whatever the reason for selling your diamonds, from divorce to settling a family member’s estate, you will find in us a sense of professionalism and respect like no other. Contact us to set up an appointment, and we look forward to sharing our process with you.

Contact Indy Diamond Buyer

Want to learn more about selling your diamonds? Fill out your information below to schedule a meeting with our expert gemologist. We look forward to meeting you.

**By Appointment Only**

I highly recommend going to meet Indy Diamond Buyer. My husband got me a new diamond right for our 20th anniversary and we decided to sell my old one. I was pretty nervous about the process and a bit hesitant to let go of my original engagement ring, but the gemologist was extremely professional, understanding and honest about everything. We were in a private area and I felt completely safe. They made everything so easy and I highly recommend them to anyone looking to sell a diamond.
Maggie S.


It was truly a pleasure working with Indy Diamond Buyer. They took the time to make sure I understood everything and we worked out a deal that was more than fair. I have already recommended them to a co-worker and she had a wonderful experience as well.
Carol S.


I had gone to other diamond buyers before, and I was amazed at how much more knowledgeable the appraiser at Indy Diamond Buyer was. This was a completely different experience than I had in the past and I can’t say enough good things. Thank you for making the process easy for me and for being so honest and respectful.
Jeff D.